In-depth: AIDS 2008: PlusNews in Mexico

GLOBAL: Is there still hope for an HIV vaccine?

Mexico City, 5 August 2008 (PlusNews) - The road to finding an effective HIV vaccine has recently been marked by a string of disappointing setbacks, and researchers have warned that a breakthrough in this field is still a long way off. Should we give up hope?

Delegates at the International AIDS Conference in Mexico City heard on Monday that the search for a vaccine to protect against HIV infection was one of the most difficult endeavours ever, with vaccine science still "more an art than a science".

In the past year, one major vaccine trial was halted after early results showed that not only did the candidate not protect people from the virus, it may actually have put them at increased risk of becoming infected.

Last month, the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) announced it would not move ahead with a vaccine trial involving 8,500 participants, which was intended to test a candidate with similarities to the one that failed last year.

These developments have left the vaccine field reeling, with people in some quarters calling for public funding of AIDS vaccine research to be ended or diverted toward existing HIV treatment and prevention interventions.

But Tachi Yamada, executive director of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation's Global Health Programme, a major funder of vaccine research, told delegates that the recent failures in HIV vaccine trials were no reason to give up hope.

This is not a time to step away and invest less...we need to move forward with big investments

"This is not a time to step away and invest less...we need to move forward with big investments. We have to be unafraid to fail," he said.

According to Yamada, scientists have very little predictive knowledge of whether vaccine candidates will work. He called for better animal models for the testing of candidate vaccines, as existing models could not predict effects on humans.

Another challenge for clinical trials was that participants did not always follow instructions, making it more difficult to demonstrate a vaccine's effects.

Unrealistic expectations on the part of the public also continued to be a problem. "When a trial goes wrong, the immediate assumption is that it was a bad investment," said Yamada, who called for more to be done to educate the public about HIV prevention research.

Alan Bernstein, director of the Global HIV Vaccine Enterprise, admitted that the search for an effective vaccine was "at a critical crossroads". He told delegates that the challenge now was to design trials that would "advance our understanding of the human immune response to HIV".

kn/ks

See also: Trials and Tribulations of HIV Prevention Research

AIDS 2008: PlusNews in Mexico
Blog
	Stiletto heels and sewing machines . Humanitarian work - it's the new black . Sexing up safer sex . Getting hot under the collar at conferences . Politics, prevention and party dresses . The last taboo?
News Map
Hear our Voices
	Lucy Chesire: "The three big scars in my life are because of TB-HIV co-infection" Maura Elaripe: "I was forced to go through sterilisation and up to now I regret it"
Previous Conference Coverage
	Microbicides 2008 GLOBAL: ARVs in microbicide research - keeping hope alive? GLOBAL: Less silence, more science could make anal sex safer GLOBAL: Microbicides in the bedroom South Africa TB Conference 2008 SOUTH AFRICA: Drug-resistant TB demands new approaches SOUTH AFRICA: TB plan has a gap between talk and action SOUTH AFRICA: TB treatment programmes failing HIV/AIDS Implementer's Meeting 2008 AFRICA: Tailoring the HIV response to fit the epidemic UGANDA: Routine HIV testing boosts uptake AFRICA: Armies grapple with HIV among troops International Congress on AIDS in Asia and the Pacific 2007 ASIA: "Seize the opportunities of hope" ASIA: No room for transgender people in HIV funding ASIA: Migrants find the greener grass has higher risks
Links & References
	AIDS 2008 2008 Report on the Global AIDS Epidemic
In-Depth Feedback PlusNews welcomes feedback. Send your messages to feedback.

Feedback  |  Terms & Conditions  |  News Feeds  |  About PlusNews  |  Jobs  |  Donors

Copyright © IRIN 2011. All rights reserved. This material comes to you via IRIN, the humanitarian news and analysis service of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the United Nations or its Member States. The boundaries, names and designations used on maps on this site and links to external sites do not imply official endorsement or acceptance by the UN. Republication is subject to terms and conditions as set out in the IRIN copyright page.