Africa Asia Middle East Français Português Subscribe IRIN Site Map
Global HIV/AIDS news and analysis
Advanced search
 Saturday 15 December 2007
Weekly reports 
In-Depth reports 
Country profiles 
Fact files 
Really Simple Syndication Feeds 
About PlusNews 
Contact PlusNews 
Print report
SOUTH AFRICA: Corruption could harm HIV/AIDS efforts

Photo: Anthony Kaminju/IRIN
"Even where ARVs are provided free by the state, health workers may ask for 'top-up payments' or bribes."
JOHANNESBURG, 29 November 2007 (PlusNews) - No one can say for sure why South Africa, which has devoted more resources to combating HIV/AIDS than any other country on the continent, still has the highest number of infections in the world.

A new study published jointly by the South African Institute for Security Studies (ISS), a think-tank, and Transparency International Zimbabwe, part of an international coalition against corruption, attempts to offer some answers.

The report, A Lethal Cocktail, asks why dramatic increases in both government and donor spending on South Africa's HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment programmes in recent years have not translated into "positive results".

The study concludes that "corruption and poor oversight are a potentially lethal cocktail when combined with the rapacious AIDS disease".

The difficulty of following and accounting for AIDS money coming from multiple government and donor sources, some of it earmarked for the public sector and some flowing directly to non-governmental organisations (NGOs) increases the potential for corruption. However, the authors note the difficulty of disentangling actual instances of corruption from basic mismanagement and weak systems.

Most HIV/AIDS funding is channelled through provincial health departments, which have struggled to absorb and manage such large sums. The result has been several cases of provinces underspending their HIV/AIDS budgets.

Few of the people working in the health and HIV/AIDS sectors interviewed for the study could point to cases of "grand" corruption, but they reported many incidents of "petty corruption and mismanagement of resources": doctors charging for services that are supposed to be free, or the theft of antiretroviral (ARV) drugs from hospitals.

A Lethal Cocktail also highlights the role poverty plays in encouraging HIV-positive people to engage in corrupt practices, such as registering at more than one treatment centre and then selling the extra ARVs, or bribing a doctor to certify them for a disability grant.

But according to the study, it is the politicisation of HIV/AIDS in South Africa that has created the greatest space "for abuses of power by political actors in support of controversial views".

The authors argue that President Thabo Mbeki's questioning of the link between HIV and AIDS and the efficacy of ARVs has afforded protection to senior political figures and health officials who have become actively involved in the promotion of alternative AIDS remedies, or intervened on behalf of people like the controversial vitamin salesman, Matthias Rath.

Other problems with South Africa's HIV/AIDS programmes - like the delays in setting up tenders for the procurement of ARV drugs, the one-year lapse of the major prevention programme, Khomanani, and the relatively slow pace of the ARV treatment rollout - are attributed to a "lack of political commitment".

The study suggests that "the narrow legal definition of 'political corruption' ignores certain aspects, such as the lack of political will to curb a health problem or implement a life-saving policy", but Nicoli Nattrass, director of the AIDS and Society Research Unit and Professor of Economics at the University of Cape Town, is unconvinced.

"Just because Manto [Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang] supports [Matthias] Rath, doesn't mean Manto is corrupt," she said. "I'd say the issue around treatment is definitely political will. As far as rising [HIV] prevalence [is concerned], the jury's out on that question. South Africa is sitting at the bottom of a huge continental pandemic, and that's not in and of itself a sign of policy failure."

Nattrass said the report's calls for greater accountability and transparency "can only be a good thing", but she was worried that the study could feed into a "backlash" against HIV/AIDS efforts resulting from recent revelations that UNAIDS and the WHO overestimated global HIV infections.


Theme(s): (IRIN) Aid Policy, (IRIN) Care/Treatment - PlusNews, (IRIN) HIV/AIDS (PlusNews), (IRIN) Prevention - PlusNews, (IRIN) Research - PlusNews


[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]
Print report
FREE Subscriptions
Your e-mail address:

Submit your request
 More on South Africa
GLOBAL: Pledges put UN response fund within “touching distance” of target
GLOBAL: More spent on hair care than climate conditioning
GLOBAL: "Political will" needed to change climate
GLOBAL: New tool to evaluate donors
SOUTH AFRICA: Albert Van Der Walt: "We weren't stupid, we were just heroin addicts"
 More on Care/Treatment - PlusNews
LESOTHO: Grassroots solutions flourish in hard times
AFRICA: The route to the end-game
SOUTH AFRICA-ZIMBABWE: Wilson Moyo: "If it was easier to access documents, it would make our lives more bearable"
GLOBAL: Simple measures could radically reduce TB
NIGERIA: Local government slow to react to AIDS crisis
Back | Home page

Services:  Africa | Asia | Middle East | Radio | Film & TV | Photo | E-mail subscription
Feedback · E-mail Webmaster · IRIN Terms & Conditions · Really Simple Syndication News Feeds · About PlusNews · Bookmark PlusNews · Donors

Copyright © IRIN 2007
This material comes to you via IRIN, the humanitarian news and analysis service of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the United Nations or its Member States. Republication is subject to terms and conditions as set out in the IRIN copyright page.