The tuna fishing in the Azores, marine conservation in Madeira, and fishing on the mainland could be affected by changes planned for the Portuguese sea by the end of the century. A study by researchers from MARE – Centre for Marine Sciences and Environment and ARNET – Aquatic Research Network, published in the journal npj Ocean Sustainability, from the Nature group, projects that in which areas 72 marine species may find favorable habitat conditions in the mid-century (2050-2060) and by the end of the century (2090-2100).
The study then cross-references these projections with the plan that defines where fishing can take place, energy can be produced, or aquaculture can be installed in the roughly 4 million square kilometres of national maritime space, approved in 2019 and which still does not take climate change into account.
The work is released in the week in which COP31, the United Nations Climate Change Conference, ends, which is taking place in Antalya, Turkey. The ocean is among the priorities and adaptation occupies a central place in the negotiations. With concrete cases, the study identifies potential conflicts and opportunities to consider in space planning.
Azores: areas favorable to tuna could concentrate in a reserve
Tuna is the pillar of Azorean fishing, representing more than 63% of annual fish landings. In the high-emissions scenario, habitat conditions favorable to the five tuna species studied decrease by up to 23% in mid-century and up to 43% by the end of the century, in the Azores’ exclusive economic zone. The areas with the most favorable conditions move first to the north and slightly to the east. By the end of the century, projections point to a single zone restricted to the northwest of the archipelago, located within the Azores North Marine Nature Reserve, the largest area of total protection in the region’s new network of marine protected areas, where fishing is not permitted.
The overlap between the area projected as favorable to tuna and the reserve poses a challenge of coordination between fishing activity and conservation. For the authors, knowing this possible overlap decades in advance allows considering solutions. Rather than fixed zones assigned to each sector, they advocate for management capable of following the movement of species, built through dialogue among the different sectors, to prevent decisions from favoring only the most profitable activities.
Whale watching and sport fishing, two activities relevant to Azorean tourism, could also be affected. In the high-emissions scenario, the Azores are the region where habitat conditions favorable to species associated with these activities show the greatest reduction by the end of the century.
Madeira: the Selvagens as refuge
About 100 km east of the Selvagens Islands Nature Reserve, the study identifies an area that maintains habitat conditions favorable to species of conservation interest until the end of the century, in both climate scenarios. This area corresponds to the extension of the reserve proposed in 2019, which has not yet been implemented. For the authors, advancing with this extension could be strategic to make marine protection more resilient to climate changes. Madeira’s coastal waters could also maintain favorable conditions for species of interest to aquaculture until the end of the century.
Mainland: sardine shows greater resilience and offshore wind zones may host algae and mussel
Fishing sustains more than 15,000 people in Portugal and accounts for between 2% and 4% of GDP. For the 18 species of greatest commercial importance, such as horse mackerel, king mackerel, biqueirão, octopus, squid, monkfish, or sole, favorable habitat conditions decrease on average by 46% in mid-century and 49% by the end of the century, in the high-emissions scenario. Species living in the water column, such as sardine, prove more resilient, while those living near the bottom are the most vulnerable.
Along the continental coast, the zones projected for the installation of floating offshore wind farms show favorable conditions for the culture of algae and bivalves, such as mussels, which could use the structures themselves as support. This possibility would allow combining energy production and food production in the same space, with potential benefits for water quality, biodiversity, and carbon capture, as well as possibly reducing installation costs.
In the open sea, the submarine mountains of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge could function as refuges. According to the projections, 82% of the species of conservation interest modeled in the study – including seahorses, sharks, rays, turtles, and whales, as well as habitats such as seagrass meadows and kelp forests – maintain favorable conditions there under all scenarios.
Two scenarios and different implications for maritime spatial planning
The study considers two climate scenarios used in the reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). In the high-emissions scenario, associated with a strong dependence on fossil fuels, the favorable habitat conditions for the set of 72 species decrease, on average, by 46% by mid-century and 55% by the end of the century. In the intermediate-emissions scenario, the evolution up to mid-century is similar, but from then on, the reduction stabilizes instead of continuing to intensify. The projected evolution depends on the emissions trajectory and the decisions taken to reduce them.
As part of adaptation, one of the researchers’ recommendations is simple and low-cost: make the study maps available on the Maritime Spatial Planning Geoportal, the public platform of the Directorate-General for Natural Resources, Security and Maritime Services (DGRM) that allows consultation of the plan. The authors also propose strengthening marine protected areas, diversifying catches, and betting on species that are arriving to Portuguese waters, integrating fishermen’s knowledge, and preparing fleets in advance.
“From the Azores to Madeira and to the mainland, the Portuguese sea will continue to change, and we already have enough information to start planning. This study shows that the future still depends on the choices we make today, in climate negotiations and in the planning of our sea. Putting these maps into the hands of decision-makers is a simple step, which can be taken now,” says Joana Boavida-Portugal, the study’s coordinator.
The results pertain to habitat conditions, not to the number of animals or the volume of catches. They are projections associated with different climate scenarios, not certainties. The study’s first author is Elisabeth Julien and it includes Catarina Frazão Santos, Tiago A. Marques, and Joana Boavida-Portugal. The authors are affiliated with MARE/ARNET (University of Évora and University of Lisbon), the Faculty of Sciences of the University of Lisbon, the University of Oxford, and the University of St Andrews. The article is available here.